efenem
Forum Newbie
Topics: 5
Posts: 17
|
Hi,
I am a total noob here, so please advise on which Qbank is more Step-1 oriented?
I've heard people talking about Kaplan medical, but I am somehow confused on which one is better for Step 1; is it Kaplan Step 1 Qbank or Integrated Vignettes Step 1 Qbank?
And I hope to get some feedbacks on USMLErx and NBME as well.
Thanks in advanced.
|
| Kalyann
Forum Elite
Topics: 4
Posts: 523
|
A post over the internet goes like this :
When choosing a QBank, I went with USMLE WORLD (UW). It is much cheaper than the competitors Kaplan and USMLE Rx, it gets higher reviews from students that have used more than one QBank, and everything else (interface, online stats) was equal. Something of a no-brainer.
After using it for almost a month, I can say a few non-comparative things.
It’s fair. I haven’t had a question yet where I felt the wording was ambiguous or the answer was a stretch. Every time that I have looked at the options and thought to myself, “I have no idea,” it was because I really didn’t know (instead of knowing the answer and not knowing how to apply it).
It’s interesting. Each question has a full explanation (usually with an illustration or table) for right and wrong choices with a summary “Learning Objective” at the bottom. This is just a smart thing for the company to do, as every wrong answer leads to a new concept learned. I regularly go through my incorrect responses and copy down the new objective into my notes.
It’s hard. While at SGU, my favorite tests were in Pathology. Whoever wrote those tests was a sadist of the fourth order. For example:
- The test stem would have symptoms. [appendicitis with Hx of appendectomy]
- You’d have to figure out the disease. [Crohn's]
- You’d then have to realize what the appropriate treatment was. [Cortisol]
- You’d have to know the side effects of that treatment. [abd striae, bull neck]
- Finally, you can answer the question: Given this patient’s symptoms, what is the most likely side effect of his treatment? [weight gain]
Everyone complained about how hard those tests were, but I had been waiting for that type of challenge in a course my whole life. I loved those tests, and for similar reasons, I love the questions in the UW Qbank. There have been a few times where, after reading a question and figuring out the answer have thought, “That was the coolest way I have ever seen that asked.” I couldn’t give it higher praise.
If you’ve decided to use UW and are working through the questions, it might help to know how you’re doing. With each question, it will tell you the percentage of people that answer it correctly. With each subject, it will tell you your percentile against other test takers. Useful, right? I’m having a few problems with this.
The stat for “percentage that answer correctly” doesn’t say if that is on the first try or includes all attempts, including repeats. I wish there was a separate statistic for this. Your overall percentile is based on your test average against the mob, but again this can be manipulated by taking the same questions over and over (I’ve tested this myself). For the person going through the questions once without repeating, you may feel that your percentile is a little low (or just hope that it is).
Here are my percentiles on first past through all the available questions in a section. I will expand this list as I continue to cover material. You’ll notice that the scores are very low. As I mentioned before, these aren’t true percentiles as they are not compared against the mob’s first attempt and I list them here just so that people don’t feel so defeated when they take the questions themselves.
- Biostatistics (74th) - I felt very well prepared
- Behavioral Science (waiting to do Psych until later)
- Embryology (71st) - I felt well prepared
- Genetics (48th) - Curse you, Dudek and your horrible book.
- Biochemistry (79th) - I felt very well prepared
- Immunology (70th) - I felt well prepared
- Histology (32nd) - I wrote this off. Maybe I should look at it.
- Anatomy (74th) - Just for fun. I’m an Anatomy geek.
ADDENDUM: I sent an email to the USMLE WORLD team about these questions and I was pleasently surprised to see them respond the next day.
The “percentage that answer correctly” only records the first attempt of the user if the question in taken in the unused mode.
The cumulative performance is based on the entire test percentage and you are correct in assuming that the percentile might be manipulated if a person repeatedly takes the test and answers all the questions correctly. However for the percentile to skew greatly, a large number of users will have to “cheat” the system this way by repeatedly taking the same questions.
However, most of our users take the test first in unused mode and then they use other modes like incorrect or marked questions if they have sufficient time left. This might skew their overall percent by 2-3 % but over a significantly large data set this offset becomes negligible.
Hence, the presented percentile should only be used as a rough indication of where the user stands and preferably should be ignored during the initial tests.
___________________
I will do it for you, my love...
|
| GOGETA
I'm Dr. GOGETA
Topics: 298
Posts: 2,616
|
In my experience UW was the one that most resemble the exam. Either by concept or the way they made the questions.
___________________
As a general rule, the better it felt when you said it, the more trouble it's going to get you into.
|
| efenem
Forum Newbie
Topics: 5
Posts: 17
|
Thank you guys....
UW has good feedbacks in this forum, why didnt I ever think of it.
Again, thanks a lot.
|
| ShweHope99.9998
Forum Fanatic
Topics: 12
Posts: 2,502
|
Well in case like to try new kap with rekap .. short & sweet at end of qs , not every one , kaplan Q bank is on sale .
Any way , bottom line is need qs to learn & practice , so time, money no matter ppl do take kap, UW even usmle Rx & FA case , FA Qs book too .
GL 
|
| kity
Certified.............
Topics: 31
Posts: 1,067
|
UW is a learning tool too. as explanations are in detail and very good.
This is not the case with Kaplan Qbank. I feel kap Q bank can be used as assessment as I saw 200-400 Qns
But I used only UW. learning & practicing at the same time and revised again and again.
real exam for me was easier than UW but some Qn were strught forward like Kap Q bank too.
___________________
NO PAIN .. NO GAIN ..
|
|
| |
| | | | | | |
