Prep for USMLEPrep for USMLE Forum
   Forum    Step 1  Step 2 CK Step 2 CS Step 3  Match  IMGs Resources Search






Previous Topic | Next Topic  Help me choose 4 LORs of the 6 I have 




Login or Register to post messages 




Author14 Posts
  #1

year of graduation 2004
after that completed 3 years of pediatric residency
want to apply for peds residency


lor no 1 : from a professor in peds from my medical school. a very good letter.

no 2 : from the HOD Peds in the hospital where i did my residency. a more general and a bit too short Letter

no 3 : from my thesis guide in the hospital where i did my residency. again a short one but covers almost all

no 4 : a professor in the hospital where i did my residency. a very good Letter

no 5 : a very well known professor in peds from the USA. but the only interaction i had with her was during her visit to my hospital in my home country (not worked under her) i am sure she has written good stuff but i dont know what exactly.!!! (waived my right to see)

no 6 : a well known professor in public health in USA. again the only interaction i had with him was during his visit to my hospital in my home country but he offered me (i did not ask) this letter because he though very good of me...and i am sure hes written good stuff but i still dont know what (waived my right to see)


now i guess the letters i choose to send will vary from university to university that i apply but still i will send the most effective 4 to most of the universities.please help me choose the 4 .

bbb this post might take a bit more of ur time...but i guess this is a typical bbb question. please help.

___________________
PedsQuiz is updated again!!!http://pedsquiz.com/

  #2

listen...the ONLY person that have the answer is YOU

only you know the LOR best, and no one else.


___________________
Please call me by my first name on March 17 - Dr.

  #3

Good things are if the letter is long, has specific examples of things you did and are from the USA. From this try to choose the best.

  #4

hey guys, i am so worried now. 5 of my lor's were posted from my place on the same day. oASIS shows that 3 of them have reached 2 days back.I am so worried abt the rest of the 2. I had sent them via speed post.
They were sent separately, by all 5 letter writers but on the same day.

  #5

i could track my letters using the united states postal service site...they are not lost...

  #6

guys i havent seen the two LORs by the US profs. so do i still go ahead and send them or stick to the 4 from my home country as i have seen them and m sure they are all very +ve ?

___________________
PedsQuiz is updated again!!!http://pedsquiz.com/

  #7

If I were u I would use the 2 from the US and pick the best 2 from my home country....2 letters from US doctors are going to be much much worthed then 4 from your home country. I know its sad but that is just the way it is, a lot of people would wish they had US MD's LOR's so if you have them use them!!! PD's will not trust your home doctors LOR's as much as a US doctor unless your home doctor is a very trusted famous physician. For instance I only used US doctors LOR's I didn't even bother asking no one at home even if I could have gotten really nice letters... if you have those use them!!!

___________________
Keep your eyes on the stars, but remember to keep your feet on the ground....Theodore Roosevelt

  #8

Sorry if I sound not so nice but the four letters from your country are probably worth nothing since these letters are not trusted from program directors and the two from the united states are also worth nothing because you did not even work with the person who wrote them and you waived your right to actually read the letter so in reality instead of six letters your really have none

  #9

i am pretty much in the same boat..

I had not waived my right any of these letter

my scene:

3 US lors...talk in general about me...mention nothing abt my clincal knwolege..

2 from home country which talk in depth about my clincal work..

so i m going with 2 from home and 1 from US


___________________
Freedom is not worth having if it does not include the freedom to make mistakes...... Mahatma Gandhi

  #10

thanks azygos but the problem with me is that i have 4 from home which i have seen and 2 from US which i haven't seen !!!

___________________
PedsQuiz is updated again!!!http://pedsquiz.com/

  #11

hey, how important are these LORs anyway...?

i mean where in the hierarchy of credentials would you put them...?

USMLE scores, USCE with externships>> observerships, LORs, a good personal statement, Residency Experience in Home country in the same specialty one is applying for, fresh graduates vs ripe fruits....!!! , publications with peer reviewed>> non-peer reviewed,.....etc, etc....

can anyone put them in perspective for me...? and order the things in descending...?

sorry for hijacking your thread motorola, but i think this is a pertinent question here...!


___________________
A conclusion is simply the place where you become tired of thinking.

  #12

One point. If you have not waived your right to see the LORs from your home country, they carry less weight than an unseen but probably not so glorifying US LoR.

  #13

i would anytime not waive right to see rather than have a medicore reco-letter with mistakes..thats a very bad impression..

my scores are above avg and have USCE+ pulications..so i deicded not to waive


___________________
Freedom is not worth having if it does not include the freedom to make mistakes...... Mahatma Gandhi

  #14

I'd say use US LoRs and 2 best Indian LoRs

___________________
Impossible is nothing !









Login or Register to post messages


















Contact us | Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy

Copyright @ Prep for USMLE. All rights reserved.