DrVirgo Forum Hero

Topics: 1043 Posts: 3,345
| | 07/23/07 - 01:04 PM  
 
   
 
|   #1 |
-Alcohol consumption and cigarette smoking both contribute causally to the occurance of esophageal cancer. These risk factors are not independent; in face, they operate synergistacally. A study of cigarette smoking in relation to esophageal cancer that fails to stratify or otherwise control for level of alcohol consumption would be guilty of which of the following threats to validity? A. Ascertainment bias B. Confounding bias C. Design bias D. Lead time bias E. Observer bias F. Recall bias G. Response bias H. Selection bias Please answer and EXPLAIN WHY... Thanks.
___________________ Our greatest glory is not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall.
|
| sprint123 Forum Guru
Topics: 129 Posts: 870
| | 07/23/07 - 01:46 PM  
 
   
 
|   #2 |
I think it is Confounding bias since alcohol is a potential confounder before defining a significant relationship between cigarette smoking and esophageal cancer!
|
| robin082006 Forum Hero

Topics: 471 Posts: 5,125
| | 07/23/07 - 01:53 PM  
 
   
 
|   #3 |
B
___________________ The Key to Succeed is Patience.
|
| DrVirgo Forum Hero

Topics: 1043 Posts: 3,345
| | 07/26/07 - 05:13 PM  
 
   
 
|   #4 |
Right.
___________________ Our greatest glory is not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall.
|
| cirus Forum Guru

Topics: 108 Posts: 740
| | 07/26/07 - 05:29 PM  
 
   
 
|   #5 |
let me put it this way & plz tell me if i'm right.. 2 factors that will have the same effect ( so u can't tell which one is the risk factor) is a confouder bias..
|
| DrVirgo Forum Hero

Topics: 1043 Posts: 3,345
| | 07/26/07 - 06:47 PM  
 
   
 
|   #6 |
well, as I understand it now, the confounder is something that is linked to the exposure which we are studying that may lead to a certain disease. For example if we want to see if alcohol leads to cancer, alcohol is the exposure we are studying. But since people who drink alcohol also smoke, smoking is a confounder. So if there is an increase risk of cancer in alcoholics, we wonder: was it the alcohol (exposure being studied) or was it the smoking (confounder) which caused cancer in the study group?
___________________ Our greatest glory is not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall.
|
| gr8doc Forum Senior
Topics: 8 Posts: 210
| | 08/08/07 - 07:01 AM  
 
   
 
|   #7 |
B
|
|
| |
| | | | | | | |