 |  Klatt vs. Goljan
|
|
| Klatt |
samdoc, kingsofke, p53, vallia, reet, new_n_lost |
6 |
12% |
| Schneider |
26malik, general malaise, alextrinh |
3 |
6% |
| Goljan |
aml, sridevibandaru24, irin, Isther, kaity, tolito, friscan2b, truedeam59, vikramjit, carmen77, MRMAVERICK, imeln313, DrPak, sigmadx, coke, study_ing, spjokes, Dr.Dude, nari, drfax, inkspot, usmlefun, twesting2173, msduncan, lungi, hundoc, virgola82, Medusin, faraym, dncosta, success100, forumdoctor, keepgoing, Data, Jlcalisto, nayef2000, doc_clotaire, yuwa, hmmm_hmmm |
39 |
80% |
| Author | 25 Posts |
p53
Forum Guru
Topics: 51
Posts: 804
|
only your votes can make this contest of the pathology titans to be statistically reliable!
Edited by p53 on 08/27/06 - 11:56 AM
___________________
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein
|
| tolito
Forum Fanatic
Topics: 119
Posts: 2,174
|
p53, you are going to cause mutiny with this poll!! how do i choose between these 2 incredible guys??? so i abstain! schneider does not compare, his brs requires a lot of prior knowledge.
___________________
It has been a looooong hard journey but I am inches away from my destination...
|
| p53
Forum Guru
Topics: 51
Posts: 804
|
Dr. Klatt is the author of 'Robbins and Cotran Atlas of Pathology' - here you can see sample chapter from this book:
http://www.us.elsevierhealth.com/product.jsp?isbn...
You can use it in combination with 'Robbins & Cotran Review of Pathology', by the same author:
http://www.us.elsevierhealth.com/product.jsp?isbn...
Dr. Klatt is also the author of webpath:
http://www-medlib.med.utah.edu/WebPath/webpath.ht...
New 2nd edition of 'Rapid Review Pathology', by Dr. Goljan is going to be released on 11/15/2006 and it will be almost 300 pages longer than the 1st edition:
http://www.us.elsevierhealth.com/product.jsp?isbn...
Dr. Schneider is the author of 'BRS Pathology':
http://www.lww.com/product/?0-7817-6022-4
Edited by p53 on 09/10/06 - 08:56 PM
___________________
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein
|
| p53
Forum Guru
Topics: 51
Posts: 804
|
Doody's Star Rating System:
5 stars (97-100) Exceptional title with nearly flawless execution
4 stars (90-96) Outstanding title, with minor problems in execution
3 stars (69-89) Very good title, but usually with one or more significant flaws
2 stars (47-68) Average title, usually with several flaws (or one major flaw) or significant weakness versus its competition
1 star (<47) Substandard title
Robbins and Cotran Review of Pathology
Edition: 2nd
Authors: Klatt, Edward C., Kumar, Vinay,
Reviewer: Ivan Damjanov, MD PhD (University of Kansas Medical Center)
Stars: *****
Score: 100
Description
This is the second edition of the bestselling book of questions and short answers dealing with pathology for medical students. In essence, it is a companion to the seventh edition of Robbins and Cotran Pathologic Basis of Disease (Elsevier, 2005) the leading medical student textbook of pathology.
Purpose
The purpose is to provide a comprehensive review of pathology through multiple choice questions and thus allow the students to test their own knowledge of pathology. For the second edition, the authors have updated, corrected, and expanded the first edition of this book. Their goals have been achieved and the objectives fully met.
Audience
The book is aimed at medical students studying pathology in the preclinical part of the curriculum or preparing themselves to take the first part of the USMLE examination. However, it also could be used by residents in pathology studying for their specialty board examination. The authors are leaders in the field of pathology education and have impeccable credentials.
Features
This book, like the main textbook, deals with general and systemic pathology. The material is presented in 29 chapters and the last (30th) chapter represents a comprehensive final examination covering the entire pathology in 74 questions. The book contains more than 1,000 multiple choice questions pertaining to the most important aspects of pathology as currently taught in a typical U.S. medical school. Most questions are presented in form of clinical vignettes in a narrative style. The student is then expected to correlate the clinical data with the pathologic findings, formulate the diagnosis or find an explanation for various aspects of the disease, explain the pathogenesis of symptoms and pathologic changes, or provide an interpretation of other relevant findings, such as x-rays or laboratory data. There are also numerous color illustrations of macroscopic and microscopic pathologic findings. Questions pertaining to these questions test students' ability to interpret visual information. At the end of each chapter, there are answers that are also linked to the pages in the main textbook.
Assessment
This is a first-class review book prepared by two experienced educators. It is a collection of test questions and short answers for medical students studying pathology. Although the review is based on the Robbins and Cotran book, it can be used independently as well. The questions have been masterfully formulated and are designed to test students' knowledge as well understanding of pathologic processes. The emphasis is on pathophysiology, clinicopathologic correlations, and diagnosis of diseases. For each question the authors have prepared a brief answer and explanation. Students interested in additional reading can refer to the text pages indicated in one of the Robbins pathology textbooks, such as the 6th and 7th editions of the main Robbins and the 6th and 7th editions of shorter version. This is an excellent book. The first edition was highly praised by students and professors alike, and I believe they will welcome this second improved and expanded edition as well. At the present time, this book is unique and has no competition.
Robbins and Cotran Atlas of Pathology
Edition: 1st
Author: Klatt, Edward C.
Reviewer: Maura O'Neil, M.D. (University of Kansas Medical Center)
Stars: *****
Score: 98
Description
This is an atlas that incorporates gross, microscopic, and radiologic images paired with brief figure descriptions to yield an integrated, concise medical resource. The atlas is organized into chapters that mirror the Diseases of Organ Systems section in the seventh edition of Robbins and Cotran Pathologic Basis of Disease, Kumar et al. (Elsevier, 2005).
Purpose
The objective is to provide an integrative approach to medical education by combining basic science and clinical information into one resource. The atlas is designed to complement other texts in the Robbins series by presenting diseases in a visual format. As medical education continues to use an integrated approach, this atlas is very timely.
Audience
This atlas is of particular benefit to medical students and beginning pathology residents. However, any student of medicine will find the images and high yield concepts useful. The author is a second year curriculum director of a medical school and is intimately aware of the format in which medical students learn material efficiently.
Features
The chapters are organized by organ system and cover most of the major diseases. Microscopic, gross, and radiologic images are included for most diseases. For example, the chapter on diseases of the vascular system includes angiograms and the one on diseases of the gastrointestinal tract includes endoscopy pictures. Although concise, the figure descriptions are complete and include high-yield clinical concepts as well as current cytogenetic and molecular genetic abnormalities. Each section also includes normal gross, histologic, and radiologic images for comparison. In general, the gross and radiologic pictures are of high quality. The microscopic pictures convey the important points of each entity, but some of them are not the quality one expects from a pathology atlas.
Assessment
This atlas provides an integrative approach to medical education that is both aesthetically enjoyable and fun to read. Consistent with the commitment to excellence in medical education, this atlas is a superb addition to the Robbins family of texts.
Edited by p53 on 10/12/07 - 12:24 PM
___________________
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein
|
| p53
Forum Guru
Topics: 51
Posts: 804
|
Tu quoque, tolito?
___________________
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein
|
| 26malik
Forum Guru
Topics: 39
Posts: 429
|
i think goljan is a good teacher but BRS is a better book.
but how come you are comparing them with a text book author. i love Robins but i cant compare it with review books.
i agree with tolito that you will cause mutiny with this poll. ;-)
___________________
There is always hope
|
| tolito
Forum Fanatic
Topics: 119
Posts: 2,174
|
' tu quoque' see mjl1717, i told you this will start a mutiny.
___________________
It has been a looooong hard journey but I am inches away from my destination...
|
| p53
Forum Guru
Topics: 51
Posts: 804
|
26malik
first of all, we are comparing here the authors with all their books (or other activities) as their merits, not the single books with each other.
also, in the 'Robbins' family we have textbooks ('Robbins & Cotran Pathologic Basis of Disease', 2004, 1552p. and 'Robbins Basic Pathology', 2002, 873p. ), as well as reviews; both 'Robbins' books by Dr. Klatt ('Robbins & Cotran Atlas of Pathology', 2006, 512p. and 'Robbins & Cotran Review of Pathology', 2004, 432p.) are reviews, not textbooks!
So, you can compare these reviews by Dr. Klatt to the reviews by Dr. Goljan and Dr. Schneider easily.
I guess you should be more careful when you are reading something.
tolito
what do you mean under 'you too see mjl1717'?
___________________
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein
|
| p53
Forum Guru
Topics: 51
Posts: 804
|
aha, now I understand - you just have confused my nick-name with that of mjl1717 - I guess that's because of the numbers after the letters in both of them.
Edited by p53 on 05/25/06 - 01:17 AM
___________________
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein
|
| general malaise
Forum Guru
Topics: 14
Posts: 433
|
sorry p53 i agree with malik. first of all your poll asks who is the "best pathology guy" not who's books are better. remember your biostatistics p53, in order to be "statistically reliable" they should be judged on equal planes. i think its unfair to judge them on this stand point unless schneider and klatt released audio lectures themselves or we all go sit in on one of their lectures at their respective schools. if u want to get specific than in my opinion schneider's review is better than goljan's. though both their questions pale in comparison to klatt's. some say robbins review can be used as a stand alone review but i've found it more useful as a kickass question source. also if you are generalizing why not include in your poll stanley robbins himself, since his legacy is never more than two feet away from where i study everyday.
___________________
"El respeto al derecho ajeno es la paz" Benito Juarez
|
| p53
Forum Guru
Topics: 51
Posts: 804
|
OK, general malaise, let's discuss it:
first of all, Dr. Goljan has NEVER officially released his audio lectures himself - in fact, he was 'hacked' (there is a proper term for this action, but I can't remember it now) - these audio lectures are illegal, so we can't take them in the account; I agree with you, that maybe Dr. Schneider or Dr. Klatt are even better lecturers than Dr. Goljan (for example, Dr. Klatt has got 'Excellence in Teaching' award many times - http://med.fsu.edu/FacultyProfile.aspx?activeDire...), but we don't have any data to judge about this - so, Dr. Goljan's audio lectures are out of consideration.
About GREAT Stanley Robbins - 26malik has complained that I'm comparing the author of the textbooks to the authors of the USMLE reviews - as I already have said, that's not right - Dr. Klatt is the author of reviews, not textbooks; now you are suggesting exactly the same thing, 26malik has complained about - to include the author of the big textbook in this poll!
Edited by p53 on 08/27/06 - 08:46 PM
___________________
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein
|
| general malaise
Forum Guru
Topics: 14
Posts: 433
|
yes i'm aware that goljan audio is bootlegged i only meant that it would be good to listen to schneider and klatt teaching in order to better compare. if we don't count the audio and since i consider klatt's review to be more a practice question book than actual review i will have to cast my vote for schneider
___________________
"El respeto al derecho ajeno es la paz" Benito Juarez
|
| 26malik
Forum Guru
Topics: 39
Posts: 429
|
if you are taking Goljan Audio out of consideration, than it means that you are comparing not "the Best Guy" , but the best author. And here , though dr. Klatt is author of many great books, both text and review, you are comparing him with two other guys who are authors of pathology review books. So I still dont think its right comparison . It will be like comparing Guyton with Costanzo.
Edited by 26malik on 05/25/06 - 09:19 PM
___________________
There is always hope
|
| p53
Forum Guru
Topics: 51
Posts: 804
|
general malaise
who said that you can't review by doing practice questions? I even think that it's the best way of reviewing!
anyway, besides his 'Robbins and Cotran REVIEW of Pathology', Dr. Klat now has released 'Robbins and Cotran Atlas of Pathology', which is heavily illustrated concise and brief text review.
26malik
as I already said, Dr. Klatt is the main author of only 2 review books, not the textbooks! can you name the textbook by Dr. Klatt? in both 'Robbins & Cotran Pathologic Basis of Disease' and 'Robbins Basic Pathology' textbooks, Dr. Klatt isn't even the co-author!
about 'guy' and 'author' - hare I can't disagree, so I'm editing my poll.
Edited by p53 on 05/25/06 - 11:09 PM
___________________
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein
|
| tolito
Forum Fanatic
Topics: 119
Posts: 2,174
|
see p53, i warned you!!!! we have very intelligent and loyal people on this forum!!
yes i made a mistake with your name. i do not confuse you both in my mind cos you have 2 different characters.
___________________
It has been a looooong hard journey but I am inches away from my destination...
|
| friscan2b
Forum Guru
Topics: 86
Posts: 447
|
Well, these are my 2 cents: Goljan is fantastic in my opinion, and his materials have helped me tremendously. If I were to go back in time, I would review Pathology from Goljan again. I recommend his stuff very, very highly!
A
|
| p53
Forum Guru
Topics: 51
Posts: 804
|
OK - let's look at the results of the poll
- I guess this forum is too much Goljan-oriented.   
___________________
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein
|
| coke
Forum Newbie
Topics: 0
Posts: 10
|
|
| p53
Forum Guru
Topics: 51
Posts: 804
|
Klatt
Attached Files:
klatt.jpg (9 KB, 25 downloads)
___________________
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein
|
| p53
Forum Guru
Topics: 51
Posts: 804
|
Schneider
Attached Files:
schneider.jpg (9 KB, 10 downloads)
___________________
"Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." - Albert Einstein
|
|
| |
| | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | | |
You don't have permission to post.
|
