Prep for USMLEPrep for USMLE Forum
   Forum    Step 1  Step 2 CK Step 2 CS Step 3  Match  IMGs Resources Search






Previous Topic | Next Topic  please someone explain this Q 




 



Author11 Posts
  #1

A 24-year-old woman with no history of cardiovascular disease has a routine physical examination before starting a new job. Cardiac auscultation revealed that her second heart sound had a noticeable split during inspiration. What change in heart function contributes to the splitting of the second heart sound upon inspiration in this patient?
Answer Choices Correct answer Your answer
A. Left ventricular afterload increases
B. Left ventricular preload increases
C. Right ventricular afterload decreases
D. Right ventricular afterload increases
E. Right ventricular preload decreases




  #2

Physiological S2 splitting: inspiration-->decreased intrathoracic pressure--->increased venous return to right heart-->increased right heart preload.

I look for increaed right ventricular preload but no see. So I go with D


___________________
The Key to Succeed is Patience.

  #3

my answer was D also. But the correct answer is C! and I don't understand why?

  #4

Option C (Right ventricular afterload decreases) is correct. More negative intrathoracic pressure on inspiration increases transmural pressure across the pulmonary vasculature, dilating vessels and reducing impedence (afterload) to the right ventricle. Duration of right ventricle ejection is longer, delaying pulmonic valve closure.

here is the explanation! I don't get itshaking head


  #5

Neither do I.

Do not understand the last sentence.


___________________
The Key to Succeed is Patience.

  #6

hmmm....how i understand it is its basically saying that during inspiration pulmonary vascular resistance decreases therefore allowing more blood to be pumped out of the RV, and since more blood being pumped out it causes the delay of pulmonary valve closure since there is increased pressure in RV

___________________
"El respeto al derecho ajeno es la paz" Benito Juarez

  #7

Physiological S2 splitting: inspiration-->decreased intrathoracic pressure--->increased venous return to right heart-->increased right heart preload
therefore right ventricular output is increased,then pulmonary vessels expand and resistance toblood flow from pulmonary artery to rt ventricle decreases(afterload) so that blood flows easily to pulmonary circiut and volume of blood in pulmonary circuit increases....so rt ventricular afterload decreases..

  #8

Dear drpkaur,

The question asks what change contributes to splitting, not simply the change associates with splitting. That make people confuse.


___________________
The Key to Succeed is Patience.

  #9

I think both generalmalaise and drpkaur are right

  #10

generalmalaise decreased afterload means that less resistance to blood outflow so less time is needed for blood to eject out of right ventricle! why do you say more time

  #11

hi guys
i searched for this info here and there and now i found that in detail as follows ok-mechanism of physiological S2 splitting: During inspiration,more neg intrathoracic pressure-blood is drawn into thorax and the the right ventricular stroke volume increases.the duration of Rt ventricular systole lengthens and P2 component is slightly delayed...Conversely the left ventricular stroke volume falls during inspiration because the greater negative intrathoracic pressure enlarges the capacity of the left atrium and pulmonary veins and reduces left atrial pressure and hence left ventricular filling and stroke volume ..thus the Left ventricular systole is shortened and A2 occurs earlier and P2 later so that the splitting of the second sound widens...........
During expiration ,the changes are exactly opposite and the splitting narrows.....
this is the whole process regarding splitting S2....rest i have made clear earlier in my previous message..







You don't have permission to post.




Login or Register to post messages in this topic





















Contact | Leaders | Disclaimer | Privacy

Copyright @ Prep for USMLE. All rights reserved.