Prep for USMLEPrep for USMLE
         Forum      |     Resources New Posts   |   Register   |   Login





 Longitudinal v prospective study?  




Post Reply  
  • 0/5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5


Author2 Posts
  #1

What is the difference between a longitudinal study that follows subjects forward in time and a prospective study, which does the same?

For example why is the following a longitudinal rather than a prospective study?

"In a study, a group of people are exposed to an environmental toxin but are not treated. Instead, they are observed over time on a standard set of measures to ascertain the potential effects of the toxin."

Is it because it involves an intervention at the very beginning (the environmental toxin exposure) while a prospective study doesn't involve any intervention at all?

I'm confused here sad
Any replies will be much appreciated smiling face




  #2

First, remember horizontal and longitudinal. Horiz means from left to right or vice-versa. Longit means from top to bottom or reverse.

There are 2 studies – Experimental and Observational.

Longitudinal study is an OBSERVATIONAL only and it is done by Cohorting.

Cohort has 2 methods:
1. PROSPECTIVE – when you start counting the cases from present time (today) to onwards (till tomorrow or uncertain FUTURE times)
2. RETROSPECTIVE- when you start searching ( &collecting) the cases from today to PREVIOUS days ; i.e. PASSED time cases

In other words: all Prospective studies are longitudinal studies but longitudinal studies are NOT ONLY Prospective studies! Prosp study itself is a Longi but Longi can be also a Retrosp.

For your specific question:
Longi does multiple observations for EACH INDIVIDUAL over a certain period of time.
Prosp does multiple observations for a GROUP OF PEOPLE over a certain period of time.

Actually, there is no much difference between these two terminologies; and I think one can use both. But the term longitudinal is more specific than other.

This is what I know about it.

Thanks
Lute
PS.!I want to know from other colleagues whether I am right as well.






Bookmark and Share





Login or Register to post messages








show Similar forum topics

Cohort vs. Longitudinal Study
To bbb; Prospective observership in CAF?
prospective training in CAF
show Related resources

Kaplan USMLE Step 1 Home Study Program
Family Medicine (National Medical Series Questions and Answers for Independent Study)
Premier Review Home Study Kit








Advertise | Support | Privacy | TOS | Premium | Contact